Journey to the Motherland

Journey to the Motherland

Benef, Paul, and Trecia discuss traveling back to the homeland of their parents and the potential awkwardness of not fitting in or speaking the language. Paul interviews Magd, a Danish man of Palestinian heritage. Tim shares his story of visiting Korea for the first time.

[00:00:00] Hello everyone, welcome back to another episode of Rhythm Amit Roam. I am one of

[00:00:14] your hosts, Benef and I also have my friends Paul and Trecia. And we like to talk about encounters

[00:00:22] while traveling. So those cultural encounters, those misconceptions, similarities, differences

[00:00:28] or those culture clashes that we have, were things just to be a little bit crazy to us because

[00:00:34] we're foreign, we're American. Yeah, we're so today we're talking about people that, for example,

[00:00:44] my style, if I'm half afghan, half american and what it's like in an American, correct?

[00:00:51] Black, yes, sure. Just saying the more specific. Okay, so this topic is interesting

[00:00:59] because I'm half afghan, but I've never been to Afghanistan. So what would it be like for me

[00:01:05] to travel back? Not knowing the language, not fully understanding all the cultural nuances?

[00:01:13] Yeah, like that's very, very interesting. Like it didn't even get to travel

[00:01:16] to Afghanistan in the military, which would have been definitely fascinating. Well, so I know.

[00:01:23] That wouldn't be an interesting. No, I wouldn't have then. I mean, I would have felt safe,

[00:01:28] because it's not a safe country to travel to, but well, I'm not being American. I don't know.

[00:01:34] So that's my point. That was our joy. That was our joy. That was our joy. Yeah, yeah.

[00:01:38] No, but I mean like because of the heat of why we were there, I don't think it would have been

[00:01:44] the experience that you probably would have wanted. But still, but so the fact that I don't

[00:01:50] understand the language like that's a huge dead giveaway, right? That I'm not, right? 100% afghan.

[00:01:57] I don't understand all the cultural things and I'm female. So there's definitely

[00:02:02] difference with the way they treat women over there, which I would probably not be down with.

[00:02:06] So I probably would have felt comfortable having my weapons with me, but I might have

[00:02:11] still had to have worn the head scarf. I think some women did when they were,

[00:02:14] had to go out and about. And then, so what I had been, like say I was traveling just with my family,

[00:02:22] what I've been discriminated against, I don't know. And so that's what we're talking about

[00:02:30] people that travel back. So we have, we have some, you know, we've used Tim a lot, but we do have

[00:02:36] an interview or I've clipped with Tim because he's Korean, ethnically Korean, but, you know,

[00:02:42] group American went back to Korea. So he's got some stories to share about that. And then Paul,

[00:02:47] met a man in Denmark who, yeah. I mean, that was, that was,

[00:02:53] building and I don't want to say well, you know me because my ear is always, you know, listening

[00:02:58] to everything around me and stuff like this too as well. And it was interesting I was out in Copenhagen,

[00:03:06] Denmark just, you know, visiting and also meeting up with old friends and stuff like this and decided

[00:03:13] to just hop on a plane and go there for the weekend. And I was eating brunch and overheard,

[00:03:21] you know, this young adult, he's in his 20s I believe. And he was talking with what looked

[00:03:28] to be a friend of his or something like this and he was talking about, you know, either he wasn't

[00:03:34] angry but he was just like, like, why do I need to tell it or not, whatever, but I just heard the word,

[00:03:43] oh yeah, and I have to go back to Palestine and, you know, and I live here in Denmark.

[00:03:49] Those are the only two things that I kind of picked up on. I was DNA Z. And then I lived, I literally

[00:03:55] kind of like looked and then he looked in my way and then I just basically said, oh, you're from

[00:04:01] the Middle East, you're Palestinian and he's kind of was like taking back and from there,

[00:04:07] small talks, small talk and he mentioned that well his family lived in, is from Palestine, but

[00:04:15] he's was born in Denmark, but he has his family lives in Israel. So I have all confused now.

[00:04:25] That's what you know, you're taught and you're just like, yeah, how does that work? I thought,

[00:04:31] you know, whatever. And I just literally just was like, you know what this is kind of interesting

[00:04:36] and introduce and told him about, yeah, and told him about, I do a podcast with two hosts, co-hosts

[00:04:43] and would love to see it, you'd be interested in, you know, sharing your story with me on your

[00:04:49] travel back and all this other good stuff. And being that you live in Copenhagen Denmark

[00:04:56] and was born in Copenhagen Denmark, your experience is because it has to be fascinating of an experience.

[00:05:04] Hello, I'm Mac, my name is Mac. I'm 21 years old. I'm Palestinian living at a

[00:05:12] born and Denmark. I'm curious to find out how was it growing for your from Denmark,

[00:05:19] but you're Palestinian, you're immersing yourself into the Danish culture and also being, you know,

[00:05:26] Palestinian, what was that like? Was there did you find it easy to immerse yourself there?

[00:05:34] Or what was it like with a cultural? I have like personally I've never had a problem to immerse

[00:05:42] myself, let's say in just different situations or especially here in Denmark, I haven't,

[00:05:51] you know, had that difficult experience, but that's also because, you know, I'm born and raised here in Denmark.

[00:05:59] So for me, like Danish culture came naturally and also the Palestinian culture came to me natural

[00:06:06] as well because we were like practicing, you know, these, you know, let's say on the

[00:06:13] religion side we were practicing these, you know, religious things at the same time. I was learning

[00:06:19] a more about my culture and I have traveled back to like Israel, but as you know, my family

[00:06:29] who have like, you keep like all the way back from where the 1948, where my roots is from,

[00:06:38] like I have traveled and you know, experience like, you know, how is it to be a foraging

[00:06:46] and your own, you know, country or where your roots are from. Did you, did you find it

[00:06:52] any challenges or was it easy or to be honest with the culture of yours and the Danish culture together?

[00:07:01] To be honest when I think about it, I've had a hard time, you know, fitting in when I have been back

[00:07:09] to visit family down in Israel. Okay. Yeah. I find it actually more difficult there because people

[00:07:17] or families ask me like, oh, what is best Denmark or how's that? And I'm just like, oh, they're

[00:07:24] both good and then, you know, it was this ongoing discussion but here in Denmark, it wouldn't

[00:07:31] like, I would barely meet anyone who, you know, would ask me this, like, especially because they don't

[00:07:38] know where I'm from and it's not like, it's not at all. Oh, very from you don't look like this,

[00:07:44] you know, it's like me talking to another person. Okay. I'm not, you know, getting, you know,

[00:07:50] judge as being Arab, our Muslim or this and that. That's not good. You said that you're a family

[00:07:56] that lived in Israel year from Palestine and that's interesting because I know the media may get

[00:08:02] seem like, you know, this big craziness and no way you can, you know, immerse yourself into culture

[00:08:10] and get along. It's just tell me how that was like, and is that something that was easy, you know,

[00:08:17] living, you know, family members living in Israel? That's the thing like we automatically go back to

[00:08:25] why social media is both a good and like, a bad, like, a bad, like, of course you have good

[00:08:35] side and bad side, the bad side of social media in this context is like, you know, on social

[00:08:41] media you see, oh, it's the Palestinians against the Jews. And okay, yeah, someone have that mindset

[00:08:50] and even, you know, I've met Arab people or just Muslim people who have also had that mindset

[00:08:58] living here in Denmark, you know, watching the media and also like, haven't like, experience

[00:09:05] like the Jews point of view, like, but just me, like even for my side I see that's even

[00:09:13] Arabic people have this, you know, first out of old Jews are this bad because they did this and that

[00:09:20] was it, was it, was it? Did you find it a problem culturally? Culturally I haven't found a problem.

[00:09:27] You guys remember to immerse each other. Yeah, yeah, my family, like we've all like immerse with

[00:09:32] others, not like, oh, I'm this year that like my family back in Halstein, like they have Jewish

[00:09:40] friends, best friend, you know, they get so good along and, you know, work together and even my own

[00:09:47] uncle, like he was married to a like Jewish woman and like religion when it came to religion,

[00:09:55] it was a problem. But at the end, you know, the family, you know, they accepted and it wasn't like

[00:10:02] then oh now it's a problem we have to, you know, live after her or if she has to live after him,

[00:10:09] it was just, you know, natural we got along and like just in general I've seen my mom who also

[00:10:16] speaks Hebrew because, and I've seen how she got along also you know with other Jewish people like

[00:10:23] if it's in a store, if it's in a restaurant and if somebody's the person with the

[00:10:29] niche of this culture. Exactly and my mom wears the hijab so you know, you automatically see

[00:10:35] where she is from but that hadn't made a difference and that's where, you know, again social media

[00:10:42] like gives you the wrong perspective, like that oh it's this against them no. It's like we have to

[00:10:50] build our own point of view, we have to experience things ourselves and that's like how like

[00:10:59] that's how I have like gotten my or what you say that's how I have,

[00:11:05] you know, make sure that people understand that people can coexist. Yeah that's how you

[00:11:13] created my, you know, you know, you know, you know, you know, you know, you know, you know,

[00:11:19] because what they see on TV or social media exactly and but I still, I still had a problem

[00:11:26] and this mindset we can immerse with the Jewish people even though I had this ongoing married to

[00:11:32] this Jewish woman because again I see all this and I'm just like what the fuck, why are they

[00:11:38] treating us like that from our past but at the end, like just this last year I have myself

[00:11:44] like researched and done this and that because I have heard things from what I was little

[00:11:50] and seen some things but you know, I have researched it myself to see is it true and what can I learn

[00:11:58] and that's why I know personally I don't want to make a fact or just something before,

[00:12:06] you know, I see it an experience in my life. So what I found interesting is that he didn't

[00:12:12] experience any discrimination, but growing up in Denmark, it's almost it's amazing and it's

[00:12:20] really shocking. Yeah, I was a little bit, I mean I don't, perhaps I don't know that much about

[00:12:27] how the Daines react to immigrants. Well I do so I can give a little bit of it because I

[00:12:33] gave many, many times and in case whoever traveled to first of all Denmark is a lovely country

[00:12:41] I love Copenhagen and I've been there before there was an influx of immigrants

[00:12:50] early 2000s and stuff like this so it was very white. I mean I'm just not going to

[00:12:56] sugarcoat it and then I think I don't remember where it just started but it started at some

[00:13:02] point where there was an influx of immigrants moving into the Scandinavian countries and it's,

[00:13:08] I would say it was recent as much as 10 years or less. This this influx happening. When that happened

[00:13:15] there started to be a little bit more unease maybe and protests maybe here and there and then

[00:13:23] there have been issues where I've heard when I used to travel for work where people would tell me

[00:13:31] stories of oh yes they're coming in and they didn't use they just used the word they so it was

[00:13:38] interesting and fascinating to hear this and the way how they were speaking kind of things so there was

[00:13:43] a just reclurification they meaning they mean in general or they mean immigrants is it in a

[00:13:52] umbrella of you know umbrella? No there were specifically talking about Middle Eastern because that was

[00:13:56] that was what you Middle Eastern Middle Eastern and so I wonder if like if you had interviewed

[00:14:03] his parents if they would have experienced something different since he was born they must obviously

[00:14:08] grew speaking Danish and grew up with a culture going to Danish school and he didn't know anything

[00:14:13] else more and I mean different and you heard him very confidently in his interviews that he never

[00:14:21] experienced him as and I would definitely suspect you know that there would be a difference because

[00:14:27] probably and you probably maybe in relate to this been from the Middle East as well is that you know

[00:14:35] the parents probably wishes that he was a little bit more Palestinian acting maybe versus Danish

[00:14:45] acting because I think this was more of I got this kind of off the cuff not on the interview part where

[00:14:55] there are things that his family wished he would be more like meaning of Mary and to a

[00:15:04] Palestinian culture culturally yes more culturally like you know the Palestinian culture travel more

[00:15:14] Palestine and Israel for that matter he does get some of the culture because I believe he

[00:15:20] practices you know some of the religion right he did but yeah like traveling back to Palestine he's

[00:15:28] or Israel where they live and that's that blue one like he had a hard time fitting in

[00:15:35] because he's he's Danish I mean it would be that would be the same like I'm American I

[00:15:44] identify as being American not African if I'm trying to have canistern it's going to be mighty

[00:15:49] strange for me to adopt and rule there without even making the language I he at least

[00:15:56] I believe speaks the language he speaks Arabic he speaks Arabic but yeah I think yeah and I think

[00:16:05] what makes it well least mind blowing for me is because like I said earlier the family lives in Israel

[00:16:15] well so what I find the advantage that I find that he has is that he speaks Arabic

[00:16:23] so he's got that at least without the language it's really really hard to have a connection

[00:16:29] and I'm taking Farcee right now for the current time in my life trying to learn but there's

[00:16:35] so many people that are trying to connect with their roots and by by the language so they

[00:16:44] they may be speak Farcee with their parents but it's like bad Farcee you know like improper

[00:16:50] grammar or they don't know how to read right because there are it's kind of difficult to find

[00:16:56] in American places to learn how to read and write yeah it's so they you know but that's like he

[00:17:02] has that already um I'm in fact like your mom is from Belize but they speak English there so that

[00:17:11] definitely made it easier to have a connection and yeah definitely was easier I mean it's very

[00:17:17] similar to you know the Jamaican Potswell which I know Paul you can identify with but um which you

[00:17:22] know any cre- and it's called Creole which is basically an origin every place has a Creole

[00:17:29] broken English kind of thing yeah it's a broken English but Creole basically is and everyone has

[00:17:34] a Creole really from their origin which is just an origin of that language so so yeah and to see

[00:17:43] a written it looks like a completely different language honestly but it's funny actually when we

[00:17:50] definitely at least possible definitely a different writing and it's funny yes it's a little

[00:17:58] it's a little different it's funny too when we when we when we actually speak it actually sounds dirty

[00:18:05] because we always make a we make a joke about that too but but no it definitely was easier for us

[00:18:13] than that in that regard but um it is something about that connection that you can have you know

[00:18:19] that you only have with you know with your family and and there is a definitely as a

[00:18:27] definitely is a definitely a connection that you have with your family or with your culture when

[00:18:31] you're able to do that and and not not having that and wanting to discover that you know and I

[00:18:40] definitely know that my family I think they felt they found it very important that I knew

[00:18:45] where I came from and I know I wanted to discover that I wanted to know what that was and

[00:18:51] I wanted to have a deeper meeting with that man so it's so really important to me yeah

[00:18:56] yeah what was that like for you traveling back to the motherland well it I mean for me it was

[00:19:04] it was well you know just from my origin story as you can see it with it really kind of form

[00:19:11] formed to me really um from early on it it kind of um I don't know I kind of really

[00:19:22] kind of gave me my basis really kind of home what home what was you know kind of made me

[00:19:28] and formulated me to who I you know I am it kind of gave me those basic principles right

[00:19:33] and understand it and that's what I felt like he was trying to you know really what he was trying

[00:19:38] to portray for him when he went back home so when he that's why when he went back

[00:19:44] he didn't feel accepted because there was that feeling for Paul it what did it feel like

[00:19:51] hmm it was it and I can relate to his side in saying it to it because there is and

[00:20:01] I probably get you know some some people agreeing with me from my Jamaican roots

[00:20:08] that you know obviously traveling number one it's very like Jamaicans are very very powerful

[00:20:16] like strong minded you know you know you know you know you know the flag and Jamaica is

[00:20:25] that little country that produces lots of great athletes and and food and all this other stuff

[00:20:31] but I know when I travel there because there sometimes there is you feel like I where I felt

[00:20:37] like I needed to get accepted by my family that's still living there because a lot of times

[00:20:45] obviously I was born in America all my family is Jamaican I was born in America so I am Jamaican

[00:20:55] ish you know in Jamaican like they would say but and I talk potwood and I can do all that other

[00:21:01] good stuff but I'm just not all the way because of the fact that you know wasn't really born there

[00:21:09] so I had to do overtime and overdrive to like be like look dammit my damn parents are from here

[00:21:17] and everybody else is from here so you know I'm not a young team you know I am you know everything

[00:21:25] in one so I have to I have to work overtime yeah and being able for them to like I felt

[00:21:34] like I needed to get acceptance yeah like you have to work harder to get accepted to feel

[00:21:39] absolutely good on it yes and that's it was that was interesting to me

[00:21:46] that I was relating to that and you know I loved it trust me you know there's nothing like

[00:21:53] you know a whole bunch of your family members and friends and everything like that and you know

[00:21:59] food is the celebration of life for us and you know shit chatting and the experiences so

[00:22:09] I just thought and to this day I still feel like I need to feel like hey look I am fucking Jamaican

[00:22:20] and I think that's what you experience is the same thing that the Tim talks about that

[00:22:25] sensible longing and like trying to find it because he you know he talks about growing up in white

[00:22:34] Indiana but then you know trying to go back to Korea or even to the west coast where there's a bunch

[00:22:40] of you know Asian population there yeah good for Indiana and so Indiana is very

[00:22:47] and I mean I'm an adoptee so my family is the driminant I was so that's the only world that I

[00:22:54] knew is very isolating no one plays that being the only Asian kid was not put on miles yeah

[00:23:02] you know and I know there's no Asian community because like some some parts of the United States

[00:23:06] out of the United States there's some not right you know so did you ever travel to any other

[00:23:13] parts of the United States for their worries and please actually what when I joined the Navy when I

[00:23:18] listed the Navy in the 17th year first place in what was San Diego okay and my get hot

[00:23:24] California in general especially Southern California it is Asian but that like a different experience

[00:23:30] you know I'm not alone that's other Asian Americans here I'm glad you asked that because it is

[00:23:35] probably not what you would expect um it is the one time in my life when I thought to myself

[00:23:41] I should feel like I belong to the one time in my life finally when I don't feel weird or out of

[00:23:46] place and I'll be honest because I spent my whole life in such a little I don't think I've never been

[00:23:52] more uncomfortable now when I was surrounded by all these Asian people I felt like I didn't belong

[00:23:57] with them either because I didn't speak fluently Korean or Chinese or you never any other Asian language

[00:24:05] and then the the honest Asian Americans are they can actually be sometimes most races people

[00:24:12] that I've ever had to deal with really only if you want to they call us people like me

[00:24:18] Korean is not using particular or anyone else who just grew up with a that I thought of like family

[00:24:23] they call us pianos

[00:24:26] right at the inside yelling outside or a week as you know they're not heard that

[00:24:30] making one okay but that was in the United States that was here yeah that was in California now are these

[00:24:36] like people that just like immigrants or they people that were born and they're almost all

[00:24:41] first generation okay so that their parents were direct immigrants from somewhere and they're the

[00:24:46] first generation so they speak fluently English they made a big list but they also spoke

[00:24:51] they grew up but you're raised in a Korean household that's what being a different

[00:24:56] and then when you were stationed in Korea you had like a similar that was even more than

[00:25:02] because then the Koreans they were just if you thought of us to what I was because I you

[00:25:07] hear me speak as terrible Korean and they're like are you Chinese? and like no you Japanese?

[00:25:16] no like where are you from and I'm like the US and America and they're like what Korean

[00:25:23] right like you know how do you sound like yes I'm Korean but they're like why do you talk like that

[00:25:29] and I stopped doing it eventually but like it felt like every time I cut my tax

[00:25:35] I had to explain that like a nice story of like you need a recording you know you're

[00:25:42] you be a mean in the dollar she's I am I'm a I'm a yeah some Korean but I'm a doubt these so I

[00:25:48] don't I'm sorry my Koreans not so good but there's the Barnes community in Korean

[00:25:53] the doubt these yeah now that yeah yeah okay no because that you know it started with a Korean

[00:25:57] more which ended in 1953 so the first wave that we those guys now are you know in their 60s

[00:26:04] so yeah so what I was you know my thought just keep going back and I feel like I'm tripping

[00:26:13] over my words because the the theme that just keeps coming back to me is you know when I was trying

[00:26:19] to explain myself between our two interviews is just you know mag and and and and Tim is every time

[00:26:28] I know that I go back to believes and and every time that I think back you know it's trying to

[00:26:35] recreate that feeling because to me believes is home you know it's it's the it's the feeling of

[00:26:43] home that's that's what I'm getting I can't bring it's words because it's a feeling home

[00:26:48] believes to me is home yeah and as like I said I mean belonging is is part of the feeling is stuff

[00:26:54] you know it's I can really 100% to that as well as to what mag had to say to as well

[00:27:02] you know but at the same time it's it's a sense like I said earlier it's a sense of me

[00:27:10] wanting to get their respect because as a as a Jamaican not born in Jamaica but your whole

[00:27:19] families from there I get the I don't want to say picked on but the you're not Jamaican enough you know

[00:27:26] for sure yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah but that's a feeling too you need to feel respect you need to

[00:27:32] feel respect you know as well right but but I should do that because I you know what I mean

[00:27:38] I don't know how to even put it in the words but it's like yes it is a feeling but it's like you

[00:27:43] have to get initiated to get someone who's Jamaican to say yep you're fully Jamaican even though I

[00:27:49] did not have I couldn't you know it was gonna be yeah yeah I mean you had different experiences

[00:27:56] and then obviously growing up in America and and believe me I talk pot to a very well and

[00:28:04] trust me you know you don't want me to lash some words out right now because

[00:28:09] what you're saying it's not enough for them is that what you're saying it's funny it is it is at

[00:28:14] time and then when we start to you know mannerisms or the way I'm talking because all of a

[00:28:21] sudden I turn it on and turn it off and then they're like what is going on here what is wrong with

[00:28:27] your voice what is this really and look look at this completely and over it really right

[00:28:32] all I mean and that's the same thing like you know Tim's Korean was not good enough for the

[00:28:38] their life yeah are you Chinese or you know but then he and he also grew up white so he was

[00:28:45] a good enough for the West Coast Asians you know the evergreen thing is like what the fuck you know

[00:28:51] like and that's the the the the part that is interesting to me like obviously I love my family

[00:29:01] and love you know the culture of where you know my family's from and everything because that's

[00:29:07] what made me and stuff like that but don't get it twisted my Jamaican can come on to win

[00:29:14] it won't for come out so when you want you know about it with me that's just an exam so yeah

[00:29:21] that's not true that I'm curious can I just ask you then the neck and you could choose to answer

[00:29:29] or not or it might be another podcast um was the reason why your parents or your mom did not

[00:29:38] teach you forcy when you were younger where it'd be easier to learn yeah so she did speak to me

[00:29:44] in pharmacy all the time you know but and I was speaking both English and forcy together so like a

[00:29:51] mix of the two languages because you know at that point maybe I was three or younger couldn't

[00:29:56] separate the two languages as kids don't and so this would have been 1978 in Madison Wisconsin

[00:30:05] okay so just get that image in your head all right it's a it's a university town so

[00:30:10] generally more diverse but I'm going to preschool and it's probably mostly white um I don't remember

[00:30:19] but I've been told that nobody could fucking understand what I was saying

[00:30:23] the only person that knew what I was saying was my mom because she spoke both

[00:30:28] so it wasn't because my dad is American right he's African American he doesn't speak

[00:30:33] farcee so they were speaking English to each other my mom and my dad so you know I didn't have

[00:30:39] that distinction to oh I speak farcee with my parents I speak English outside of the home yeah it was just

[00:30:45] both and because I didn't know it's struggling I mean I apparently no one understood what I was saying

[00:30:51] so that's like a lot of stress for a child when I'm asking for like water I don't know and

[00:30:55] all right I got to go to the bathroom and no one knows what I'm saying um so they went to a child

[00:31:01] linguist and now I don't know if this guy was white uh if by my mom and my dad are watching

[00:31:06] you need to comment was it a one because here's the advice was to stop speaking farcee now it's

[00:31:13] a 19-year-old so that sounds a lot of political and they again share better judgment you know

[00:31:21] they they just wanted me to probably not be suffering and they stopped and I never picked it up again

[00:31:29] well this has certainly been a very interesting discussion and I want to thank

[00:31:33] Magd and Tim for sharing their story so thank you also to listeners and the people watching

[00:31:42] if you liked our show please follow us comment subscribe and we hope to see you next time

[00:31:52] so